When it comes to working out, one of the most common struggles women face is finding the perfect hair tie that can withstand intense workouts without causing damage or discomfort. The right hair tie should not only hold your hair securely in place but also be gentle on your strands and easy to use. With so many options available on the market, it can be overwhelming to choose the best hair ties for your specific needs.
In this comprehensive guide, we will explore the top hair tie options that have been recommended by experts and fitness enthusiasts alike. We’ll delve into the key factors to consider when searching for the best hair ties for working out, including holding strength, chance of breakage, resulting crease, versatility in hair thickness, and quality and value. By the end of this guide, you’ll have a clear understanding of which hair ties are best suited for your workout routine.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Hair Ties for Working Out
Holding Strength
Different workouts require different levels of holding strength from your hair tie. Whether you’re practicing yoga, going for a run, or engaging in high-intensity interval training (HIIT), you’ll want a hair tie that can keep your hair in place throughout your entire workout. Consider the type of workouts you typically engage in and choose a hair tie that provides the necessary holding strength for those activities.
Chance of Breakage
Wearing your hair in a ponytail frequently can lead to hair breakage, especially if you’re using the wrong type of hair tie. Look for hair ties made from soft materials that won’t snag or pull on your hair. Avoid hair ties with metal fasteners, as they can cause breakage. Opt for hair ties that are specifically designed to be gentle on your hair.
Resulting Crease
Another factor to consider is the crease that certain hair ties can leave in your hair. If you’re someone who prefers to wash your hair every other day or less frequently, finding a hair tie that minimizes creases is crucial. Look for hair ties that are designed to leave minimal creasing or invest in scrunchies, which are known for their ability to hold hair without leaving noticeable marks.
Versatility in Hair Thickness
Hair thickness varies from person to person, and finding a hair tie that can comfortably accommodate your hair type is essential. If you have thick hair, opt for hair ties that can wrap around your hair multiple times without stretching out. If you have thin hair, look for hair ties that are gentle and won’t put too much pressure on your strands.
Quality and Value
Hair accessories come in a wide range of prices, and it’s important to find a hair tie that offers good quality and value for your money. While some options may be more expensive, they may also last longer and provide better performance than cheaper alternatives. Consider your budget and the longevity you expect from your hair ties when making your decision.
The Top Hair Ties for Working Out
After extensive research and analysis of the best hair ties for working out, we have compiled a list of top recommendations that cater to various hair types and workout routines. Let’s explore each option in detail:
1. Goody Hair SlideProof Hair Tie Elastics

- Price: $3 for 10
- Holding Strength: ★★★★
- Chance of Breakage: ★★★★
- Resulting Crease: ★★★★
- Versatility in Hair Thickness: ★★★★
- Quality and Value: ★★★★
Goody Hair SlideProof Hair Tie Elastics offer a reliable and affordable option for keeping your hair in place during workouts. These hair ties provide a secure hold without causing breakage or damage to your hair. While they may snag your hair when removed, their holding strength and overall performance make them a popular choice among fitness enthusiasts. They are available in a pack of 10, offering great value for money.
2. Gimme Bands

- Price: $12 for 6
- Holding Strength: ★★★★
- Chance of Breakage: ★★★★
- Resulting Crease: ★★★★
- Versatility in Hair Thickness: ★★★★
- Quality and Value: ★★★★
Gimme Bands are cloth hair ties that provide a secure hold without causing breakage or discomfort. These hair ties are washable and hold up well during workouts, even for running. They leave minimal dents in your hair and are suitable for various hair thicknesses. While they may create a slightly thicker profile, their overall performance and ability to avoid breakage make them a great option for active women.
3. Kitsch Spiral Hair Ties

- Price: $8 for 8
- Holding Strength: ★★★★
- Chance of Breakage: ★★★★
- Resulting Crease: ★★★★
- Versatility in Hair Thickness: ★★★★
- Quality and Value: ★★★★
Kitsch Spiral Hair Ties offer a unique and fun alternative to traditional hair ties. These spiral hair ties provide a decent hold without leaving noticeable creases in your hair. They are suitable for low to medium impact workouts and are particularly great for strength training or everyday use. While they may stretch out over time, they can be easily reformed with a little heat. Kitsch Spiral Hair Ties offer good quality and value for their price.
4. Burlybands Large Hair Ties

- Price: $11 for 3
- Holding Strength: ★★★★
- Chance of Breakage: ★★★★
- Resulting Crease: ★★★★
- Versatility in Hair Thickness: ★★★★
- Quality and Value: ★★★★
Burlybands Large Hair Ties are specifically designed for women with thick hair. These hair ties offer a strong and secure hold without causing breakage or discomfort. They retain their elasticity over time and hold up well during various types of workouts. While they may be slightly more expensive than other options, their durability and ability to accommodate thick hair make them a worthwhile investment.
5. Revlon Extra Thick Black Hair Elastics

- Price: $4 for 3
- Holding Strength: ★★
- Chance of Breakage: ★★
- Resulting Crease: ★★
- Versatility in Hair Thickness: ★★
- Quality and Value: ★★
Revlon Extra Thick Black Hair Elastics are an affordable option for those on a tight budget. These hair ties provide a strong hold, especially for thicker hair. However, they may be too thick for some hair types and can stretch out over time. While they may not be the most durable option, they offer a tight hold for low to medium impact workouts. If you’re looking for a temporary fix or need a hair tie in a pinch, Revlon Extra Thick Black Hair Elastics are a decent choice.
6. TailaiMei Spiral Hair Ties

- Price: $12 for 20
- Holding Strength: ★★★★
- Chance of Breakage: ★★★★
- Resulting Crease: ★★★★
- Versatility in Hair Thickness: ★★★★
- Quality and Value: ★★★★
TailaiMei Spiral Hair Ties offer a stronger hold compared to traditional spiral options. These hair ties are suitable for various workouts, including running, without compromising on holding strength. While they may stretch out during use, they can be shrunk back to their original size with a little heat. These hair ties provide minimal damage or creasing to your hair, making them a great alternative for those who prefer spiral hair ties.
Conclusion
Choosing the best hair ties for working out is essential for maintaining the health and appearance of your hair during exercise. Consider factors such as holding strength, chance of breakage, resulting crease, versatility in hair thickness, and quality and value when selecting the right hair ties for your needs. Whether you opt for Lululemon Sleek and Strong Hair Ties, Athleta Mini Scrunchies, Goody Hair SlideProof Hair Tie Elastics, or any other recommended option, you can now make an informed decision based on your hair type and workout routine. Invest in hair ties that will not only keep your hair in place but also protect it from damage, so you can focus on your fitness goals with confidence.